Dissertations/Thesis

Clique aqui para acessar os arquivos diretamente da Biblioteca Digital de Teses e Dissertações da UnB

2024
Dissertations
1
  • Selefe Gomes da Silva Neta
  • SUBNATIONAL STATE CAPACITY: THE CASE OF PIAUÍ

  • Advisor : ADRIAN NICOLAS ALBALA YOUNG
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • ADRIAN NICOLAS ALBALA YOUNG
  • ARNALDO MAUERBERG JUNIOR
  • FREDERICO BERTHOLINI SANTOS RODRIGUES
  • MARCELA MACHADO
  • Data: Feb 23, 2024


  • Show Abstract
  • Our research focuses on the subnational state capacity analysis, specifically on the Brazilian state of Piauí as a case study. The state's capacity is related to the State's ability to formulate and implement effective public policies. Here we examined administrative, economic, and coercive dimensions, understanding how these factors impact socioeconomic development. Our choice for Piauí as a case study results from a notable contradiction between its high state capacity and socioeconomic results. This research seeks to evaluate how the theory of state capacity applies to Piauí's context, identifying the determining factors of state capacity's development and the impact on results - our goal is to contribute to a deeper understanding of the complex relationship between state capacity and development at the subnational level.

2
  • ALEXANDRA EMANUELA NOVAIS SILVA
  • Brazilian federalism and the protagonism of the states: an analysis of the PNI during the COVID-19 pandemic

  • Advisor : FREDERICO BERTHOLINI SANTOS RODRIGUES
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • FREDERICO BERTHOLINI SANTOS RODRIGUES
  • ADRIAN NICOLAS ALBALA YOUNG
  • DENILSON BANDEIRA COELHO
  • CATARINA IANNE SEGATTO
  • Data: Mar 1, 2024


  • Show Abstract
  • The purpose of this paper is to analyze how the adoption of COVID-19 immunization plans by Brazilian state entities has taken place. In this way, the first chapter discusses the literature on federalism and the role conferred on each entity, together highlighting the roles of the intermediate entities in health policies. The second chapter describes the national immunization programme, its structure and how it operated during the pandemic. The third chapter sets out the methodology chosen here, content analysis. Based on this, we analyzed plans that converge with the national plan for operationalizing immunization against COVID-19, then plans that diverge, and finally plans that play a leading role. In light of this and the literature discussed, we found, as the literature on state autonomy points out, a greater divergence between plans, especially in the information on the definition of priority groups and what system would be used to record those vaccinated and cases of adverse events following vaccination.

3
  • Lucas Amorim
  • DETERMINANTS OF VARIATIONS IN THE EFFECT OF CUES ON POLITICAL ATTITUDE

  • Advisor : ANDRE BORGES DE CARVALHO
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • JULIAN BORBA
  • ANDRE BORGES DE CARVALHO
  • FREDERICO BERTHOLINI SANTOS RODRIGUES
  • LUCIO REMUZAT RENNO JUNIOR
  • Data: Mar 4, 2024


  • Show Abstract
  • This dissertation investigated the influence of political cues on individual attitudes, exploring which types of questions are more susceptible to persuasion or polarization through cues provided by party elites. The hypotheses of this dissertation suggests that political questions with a low level of political sorting (H1), where members of a group face cognitive dissonance regarding the presented cue (H2), are more influenced by political elites. The research utilized a comprehensive database containing diverse questions on political issues that were subjected to different treatments of political cues, randomly distributed among participants from a representative sample of the American electorate. The results confirmed the more demanding hypothesis (H2), to the detriment of the simpler one (H1), in treatments where the cue reflected an intuitive position of the elite, but not in treatments with counterintuitive cues. The analysis highlighted the complexity of the influence of political heuristics and emphasized the importance of the content of the questions in determining the effect of the influence of party elites. The dissertation provides an empirical basis for the debate on the variation in the effect of political cues and underscores the need to consider contextual factors for possible generalizations.

4
  • ISABELA SILVEIRA ROCHA
  • 2022 IN A NUT SHELL: Political personalism and Twitter as a polarizing platform
  • Advisor : JOSCIMAR SOUZA SILVA
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • JOSCIMAR SOUZA SILVA
  • MARISA VON BULOW
  • THIAGO APARECIDO TRINDADE
  • HELGA DO NASCIMENTO DE ALMEIDA
  • Data: Mar 6, 2024


  • Show Abstract
  • his dissertation examines political narratives on Twitter during the Brazilian presidential elections of 2022, focusing on affective polarization and political personalism. The motivation for this study arises from the need to expand understanding of affective polarization in Digital Social Media and how Twitter's specific interface influences this phenomenon distinctly for each candidate. The research aims to fill existing theoretical gaps, employing Topological Data Analysis (TDA) to identify patterns of political personalism and affective polarization, contributing methodologically with new tools for analyzing large volumes of data in political communication. The dissertation's main hypothesis is that political personalism and the platform's architecture, permeated by feelings of political alienation, favor affective polarization on Twitter. The objectives include mapping networks of political personalism and affective polarization, applying TDA in the field of political communication, identifying Persistent Homologies in narrative constellations, and relating them to Brazilian politics during the 2022 elections. The research adopts a qualitative approach, analyzing a large volume of tweets collected through data scraping techniques and using the Argos code for topological and content analysis. The main results indicate the identification of Persistent Homologies and a causal relationship between political personalism and affective polarization, centered on the figures of Bolsonaro and Lula, as well as highlighting the influence of Twitter's architecture in the process.

5
  • EVELYN MARIA APOLINARIA SANTOS ARRUDA
  • GOVERNMENT CENTER AND PRESIDENTIAL STYLE MEDIA IN THE BOLSONARO GOVERNMENT
  • Advisor : ARNALDO MAUERBERG JUNIOR
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • ARNALDO MAUERBERG JUNIOR
  • DENILSON BANDEIRA COELHO
  • FREDERICO BERTHOLINI SANTOS RODRIGUES
  • PEDRO LUIZ COSTA CAVALCANTE
  • Data: Mar 8, 2024


  • Show Abstract
  • The objective of this work is to construct and analyze the Government Center (GC) of President Jair Bolsonaro, his presidential style, classified by us as spectacular, in managing this structure and the government as a whole, and the coordination capacity of priority policies presented by his GC. In the literature review, we provide definitions and nomenclatures of what the GC would be, understood in this work as a set of units, formal or informal, that support the Head of the Executive (Cavalcante, 2018). We also present academic productions on the spectacular style and on GC and public policies. As a methodology, we apply the model presented by Cavalcante and Batista (2018) on the classification of the Government Center as structural or functional, de jure or de facto, and create two databases: one with all interactions recorded in the president's official agenda and another indicating, in the legislation that structures the Presidency of the Republic, the presence or absence of descriptors that can classify an organ in the Government Center. Additionally, we conducted interviews with three representatives who held high positions in the government to understand, in detail, the daily life of the GC and how the interviewees perceived Bolsonaro's leadership. We used the Iramuteq and R software for the analysis of the results. We dedicate a chapter to explain Bolsonaro's spectacular style based on Jones' definition (2018) and use data from 181 live broadcasts and a chronology of the most relevant events based on documentary research that allowed us to identify the spectacularization of certain themes and events. To analyze the coordination capabilities of the GC in public policies, we chose those mentioned by the interviewees and conducted a content analysis based on the interviews and bibliographic research: Covid-19 vaccination, Emergency Aid/Brazil Aid, and Digital Government. The results pointed to a present GC, but with very low leadership exercised by the President due to the high decentralization he promoted. Furthermore, the entry of the Centrão, in the second half of the government, allowed Bolsonaro to further distance himself from his own responsibilities to remain connected to his supporters and radicalize his discourse. In conclusion, although the coordinative capacity of the GC was impaired by the excessive decentralization of the president, less politicized policies achieved greater success by the GC member agencies.

6
  • Bruno Lima Teixeira
  • Gender and political careers in the Legislative Chamber of Distrito Federal

  • Advisor : DANUSA MARQUES
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • DANIELA LEANDRO REZENDE
  • CARLOS AUGUSTO MELLO MACHADO
  • DANUSA MARQUES
  • DEBORA CRISTINA REZENDE DE ALMEIDA
  • Data: Mar 12, 2024


  • Show Abstract
  • This research aims to analyze how the sexual division of political labour affects the occupation of positions during and after the passage of district deputies through the Legislative Chamber of Distrito Federal in the first, fourth, sixth and eighth legislatures (1991-1994; 2003- 2006; 2011-2014; and 2019-2022). To this end, a biographical collection of 103 parliamentarians – incumbents and substitutes who took office in these legislatures – was carried out, in order to draw a comparative profile between men and women, regarding their occupation of leadership positions (Board of Directors, party and bloc leadership and committee presidency) and regarding political opportunities, electoral and non-electoral, after their time at CLDF. The results found indicate important distinctions, during and/or after the mandate in the CLDF, between the political careers of district deputies, such as level of education, areas of training, professional activity, previous occupation of some non-elective political position or non-state political burden, acting on the Board of Directors, presiding over permanent committees and assuming political burdens in the Executive Branch. By identifying these differences between the political careers of men and women, it was possible to identify how being a woman in politics impacts access and opportunities that guide the construction of their professional political careers.

7
  • LARISSA MARTINS MARQUES
  • Gender and conservatism: political attitudes in Brazil (2018-2022)

  • Advisor : LUCIO REMUZAT RENNO JUNIOR
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • VITOR DE MORAES PEIXOTO
  • ADRIAN NICOLAS ALBALA YOUNG
  • FREDERICO BERTHOLINI SANTOS RODRIGUES
  • LUCIO REMUZAT RENNO JUNIOR
  • Data: Mar 13, 2024


  • Show Abstract
  • A growing trend of mobilizations and attacks against gender equality, sexual rights, and their activism has generated tensions around an anti-gender agenda advocated by conservative, religious, right-wing populist, and nationalist actors. Ultimately, how do the political opinions of men and women materialize during a period of alignment with a conservative agenda in the country? Is there a gender difference in the dimensions of conservatism? In what direction does this difference point? How do gender disparities persist when the statistical model encompasses other important issues for the dimensions of conservatism? The objective of this dissertation is to investigate (i) whether there is disparity in the conservative attitudes of men and women and (ii) the proportion of gender disparities in these attitudes that can be explained by religiosity, occupational status, marital status, ideology, and party affiliation when controlled for age, income, education, and race. At this juncture, the aim is to analyze the strength that gender - a social identity - holds in comparison to other attributes that also act as opinion differentiators. To achieve the results, the research utilized proportion difference tests and logistic models for multivariate analyses. The data is derived from the "A cara da democracia" project. Questions that allow the operationalization of Brazilian multidimensional conservatism were selected, aggregating thirteen survey questions into three dimensions: traditional social and moral issues, views on law and order, and social policies and economic positions. The main finding is that women are more likely to express progressive attitudes compared to men.

8
  • Izabela Graziani Alves Simas

  • When movements enter the party system: an analysis of support strategies communication from the leaders of right-wing movements and political parties
     
  • Advisor : MARISA VON BULOW
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • MARISA VON BULOW
  • DEBORA CRISTINA REZENDE DE ALMEIDA
  • REBECCA NEAERA ABERS
  • LUCIANA FERREIRA TATAGIBA
  • Data: Mar 20, 2024


  • Show Abstract
  • The present study aims to analyze the relations between self-proclaimed right-wing social
    movements and the Brazilian party system, focusing on the communication strategies adopted
    by the leaders of these movements on Facebook regarding this relationship. This work fits into
    the debate on the interaction between social movements, political parties, and populist, anti-
    establishment, or anti-political movements, seeking to identify the particularities of the
    Brazilian case. To achieve these objectives, posts from the Facebook pages of federal deputies
    Carla Zambelli and Kim Kataguiri, elected leaders of NasRuas and MBL, respectively, were
    analyzed. The data analysis was conducted in three distinct stages. Firstly, a comprehensive
    quantitative analysis of the data was performed. Next, a corpus of text was organized to allow
    for an analysis based on word clouds and similarity analyses. Finally, the posts were subjected
    to a content analysis guided by classification into categories. The results of this dissertation
    corroborate important points from the literature, such as the differences existing within the
    Brazilian right and the role of anti-Petism as a unifying element. Additionally, the data indicate
    different strategies for integration into the party system at different times, as well as an
    inconsistency between the daily political-party activities in the Chamber of Deputies and those
    conveyed on the deputies' pages on social media.

9
  • Ana Clara Martins Pompeu
  • THE CONSERVATIVE REACTION TO ABORTION IN 10 YEARS: ACTORS AT THE ADPF 54 AND ADPF 442 PUBLIC HEARINGS

  • Advisor : FLAVIA MILLENA BIROLI TOKARSKI
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • ALBA MARIA RUIBAL
  • DEBORA CRISTINA REZENDE DE ALMEIDA
  • FLAVIA MILLENA BIROLI TOKARSKI
  • REBECCA NEAERA ABERS
  • Data: Apr 12, 2024


  • Show Abstract
  • This dissertation focuses on mapping the conservative actors in the dispute over the right to abortion, from a diachronic perspective of the conservative reaction. The study spotlights specifically the impact of these actors on the judiciary, in cases mobilized by the feminist field. To this end, we identified the individual and collective actors who took part in two public hearings convened by the Federal Supreme Court (STF). The first was held in 2008, as part of the motion for breach of fundamental precept (ADPF) 54, through which the Court, in 2012, authorized the interruption of pregnancy in cases of anencephalic fetuses. The second took place in 2018, to hear ADPF 442, which calls for the decriminalization of abortion up to the 12th week of pregnancy. ADPF 54 was the first public hearing called by the STF and open to civil society. It brought together 29 actors. Of these, nine were conservatives. ADPF 442 brought together 63 speakers, 16 of them opposed to abortion. The 10 years between the two showed the expansion of conservative action, with the registration of more religious organizations acting on this front, in addition to the Catholic Church, including the change in the evangelical position from one to the other. In other conclusions, there is also a record of legal organizations with a strong presence in the second hearing and non-existent in the first. The dissertation also shows joint efforts between these different actors. The work indicates the strategic and coordinated action of the Catholic Church, but with the growth of the evangelical churches, the valorization of the law for the conservative reaction, both as a strategy and place of incidence and as a form of organization, the connection with international actors from countries that have experienced or are experiencing similar reactive processes and the rise of national actors after participating in these public hearings to the federal government also as a result of this anti-choice militancy.

10
  • Ruhana Luciano de Franca
  • Between signification and silencing: Activism to confront violence in childbirth and the reactive mobilization of the medical profession in Brazil

  • Advisor : FLAVIA MILLENA BIROLI TOKARSKI
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • FLAVIA MILLENA BIROLI TOKARSKI
  • MICHELLE VIEIRA FERNANDEZ DE OLIVEIRA
  • REBECCA NEAERA ABERS
  • LUCIANA FERREIRA TATAGIBA
  • Data: May 23, 2024


  • Show Abstract
  • Based on the questioning of the role of the medical profession in hindering the construction of an agenda to combat obstetric violence in Brazil, this research aimed to analyze the actions of the organized medical profession in opposition to the movement to humanize childbirth during the Jair Messias Bolsonaro administration (2019-2022). Using the discussion on reproductive governance and studies on gender “backlash” as a theoretical framework, with emphasis on the relational dynamics between movements and counter-movements, the dispute over childbirth and forms of medical care appeared as a dispute over the state, which mobilizes questions about plurality, participation, citizenship and recognition of demands by different subjects. Realizing that an important part of this dispute takes place in the discursive field, where signification and silencing represent the conformation of different interests, I use discourse analysis of documents from medical organizations published between 2012 and 2022 as a tool of research and analysis. I point out that the strategy of silencing by the medical profession from 2019 onwards takes place through mechanisms of democratic regression, translating into discursive delegitimation, reformulation of public policies linked to humanized childbirth and the erosion of mechanisms of inclusion and accountability. I conclude that by seeking to depoliticize the agenda in favour of respectful childbirth, the medical profession is acting to ensure the perpetuation of its authority at the expense of the autonomy of pregnant and parturient women. The reprivatization of the issue of obstetric violence is close to what has been seen as a neoliberal trend of state de-responsibility and, by being operationalized during a far-right government, shows the authoritarian contours of state selectivity.
     
11
  • Victor Hugo da Silva Alves
  • Presidential Legislative Activity: Latin America in Comparative Perspective

  • Advisor : ARNALDO MAUERBERG JUNIOR
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • ADRIAN NICOLAS ALBALA YOUNG
  • ARNALDO MAUERBERG JUNIOR
  • FREDERICO BERTHOLINI SANTOS RODRIGUES
  • MARCELA MACHADO
  • Data: May 31, 2024


  • Show Abstract
  • Presidential legislative activity has emerged as one of the most prominent and representative phenomena in Latin American politics. Democracies in the region feature institutional prerogatives that grant strong legislative powers to presidents while simultaneously enhancing control exercised by parliamentarians. These scenarios are characterized by structural and ideological determinants that permeate the relations between branches of government and can directly influence the success of proposals. The research sought to analyze, in a comparative perspective, the following question: how do certain institutional mechanisms impact the rate of presidential legislative success in Latin America? The Latin American scenario was chosen for being a representative case of presidents with significant legislative activity in contrast to bicameral systems that possess the necessary prerogatives to control such activities. The sample comprises Argentina, Brazil, Chile, Colombia, and Paraguay. The methodology consists of a quantitative analysis with panel data and the use of the mixed-effects econometric model. The results demonstrate that the fragmentation of the party system, ideological distance, and the choice of the Senate as the initiating chamber for projects are statistically relevant mechanisms for explanation. On the other hand, coalition party fragmentation did not have a significant effect, and it was identified that there is no increase in the production of legislative decrees in scenarios with low rates of legislative success. These findings lead to the understanding that structural and ideological contexts are directly associated with variations in presidential legislative success but need to be analyzed based on the perspectives of coalition governments in Latin America.

Thesis
1
  • Dermeval da Silva Júnior
  • Institutional Changes in the Water and Sewage Subsystem in Brazil between 2003 and 2020:
    An analysis from the perspective of the Advocacy Coalition Framework

  • Advisor : DENILSON BANDEIRA COELHO
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • ANTONIO SERGIO ARAUJO FERNANDES
  • ARNALDO MAUERBERG JUNIOR
  • DENILSON BANDEIRA COELHO
  • GRAZIELLA GUIOTTI TESTA
  • REBECCA NEAERA ABERS
  • Data: Mar 18, 2024


  • Show Abstract
  • This research aims to contribute to the accumulation of scientific knowledge about the process of institutional change and public policies in Brazil. To this end, she materialized a longitudinal study on the institutional evolution of the water and sewage subsystem in the country between 2003 and 2020 at the federal level. According to data from the National Sanitation Information System (SNIS), almost 32 million inhabitants were not served by a public water network, and more than 90 million inhabitants did not have access to the public sewage collection network in 2022. Furthermore, of the total sewage generated in the country that year, almost 48% was untreated. In this context, it is essential to highlight that inadequate coverage and poor quality of sanitation services are associated with the proliferation of diseases. According to the Brazilian Institute of Geography and Statistics (IBGE), almost 12 million cases of Diseases Related to Inadequate Environmental Sanitation (DRSAI) were reported in Brazil, with approximately five million hospitalizations in the Unified Health System (SUS) between 2008 and 2019. Chagas disease, diarrhea, and dysentery were the leading causes of death, representing almost 81.5% of deaths from DRSAI in this period. Regarding methodological aspects, this research was developed through a single case study, qualitative in nature, and longitudinal analysis. The case under analysis was the institutional evolution of Brazil's water and sewage subsystem at the federal level. This study was supported by content analysis and process tracing strategies applied to documents relevant to the empirical investigation and interviews with relevant actors. The analytical framework adopted in this research was based on the Advocacy Coalition Framework (ACF) and the literature on historical institutionalism and causal mechanisms, aiming to identify how and why the institutional scenario of the water and sewage subsystem changed in Brazil between 2003 and 2020 at the federal level. In this sense, the research identified three coalitions established in a competitive scenario in the water and sewage subsystem, which remained relatively stable throughout the studied period. These institutional changes occurred due to the activation of the causal mechanisms of learning, pressure, negotiation, and mediation.

2
  • ADRIANO SOUSA COSTA
  • The horizontal diffusion in Brazil of Specialized Police Stations for Women's Assistance (DEAMs) using the survival analysis methodology

  • Advisor : DENILSON BANDEIRA COELHO
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • DENILSON BANDEIRA COELHO
  • ARNALDO MAUERBERG JUNIOR
  • ARTHUR TRINDADE MARANHAO COSTA
  • MANOEL LEONARDO WANDERLEY DUARTE SANTOS
  • MARIANA BATISTA
  • Data: Mar 20, 2024


  • Show Abstract
  • The aim of this study, based on the chronological timeline of the installation of Women's Police Stations (DEAMs), is to delimit the process of diffusion of this specific public security policy throughout Brazil, determining which factors may explain the implementation of these units by governors. The purpose of this study is also to explain why some governors adopted the units more quickly than others. Using data collected by the civil police in all Brazilian states, a model was built based on the analysis of historical events. The events under analysis were the actual installations or their individualized normative provision, whichever came first; this is because it shows the government's clear awareness of this public policy. Data collected and approved by the local civil police delimited this diffusion, allowing a model to be built based on the analysis of historical diffusion events. Predictive variables were collected in order to highlight the influence of economic, criminal, population, social, political- ideological, geographical and institutional contexts on this diffusion process. Based on the assumption of bounded rationality, the research focused on the premise that the governor implements these units with an eye on political gains. All the evidence was analyzed using the literature on the diffusion of public policies, the limited rationality of governors, as well as the methodology of survival time, guaranteeing the construct internal and external validity and reliability. Survival risks were estimated using the Kaplan-Meier estimator, producing, with a little more accuracy, a model in which a few variables were adjusted. The most relevant conclusions point to the prevalence of political explanatory variables to the detriment, for example, of the expected relationship between the adoption of DEAMs and local femicide rates.

3
  • Janikelle Bessa Oliveira
  • Change in budget policy: Ideas and the institutionalization of budgeting in the Legislature

  • Advisor : LUCIO REMUZAT RENNO JUNIOR
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • LUCIO REMUZAT RENNO JUNIOR
  • PAULO CARLOS DU PIN CALMON
  • REBECCA NEAERA ABERS
  • GILMAR ANTONIO BEDIN
  • JOAO HENRIQUE PEDERIVA
  • Data: Mar 21, 2024


  • Show Abstract
  • The research proposes, as theme, to analyze the process of change in budgeting in the Legislative through the Joint Budget Committee - CMO, particularly the alterations in the institutional configuration of brazilian budgetary policy after redemocratization, assuming the new discursive institutionalism as a theoretical methodological guide. In this terms, the object of the research is the institutional adjustment in the CMO, focusing on the post-1988 period and its changing context. It seeks to answer the following questions: which ideational mechanisms affect the dynamics of the institutional design of the Joint Budget Committee - CMO? How was the process of change established in the CMO based on the critical scenario of redemocratization? Which discursive coalitions act on the institutional design and internal dynamics of the Joint Budget Committee - CMO? The research aims to identify the ideational mechanisms that act in the process of change in the Joint Budget Committee as an institution of Brazilian budgetary policy after the 1988 Constitution, understanding the relationship between institution, political agency and cognitive coalitions in the process of stabilization or policy alterations. Intensive Process Tracing is assumed as a methodological path, with the variation of theory-guided process tracing that enables a temporal and causal analysis of the sequences of events that constitute the process. Access to the database of documents related to public budgeting, its formatting in a textual corpus and further analysis, made it possible to understand that many ideals in tension after the promulgation of the 1988 constitution were already present in its initial debate and these ideas are looking for transmitters whether as a political agent or as a bureaucrat to infiltrate public policy spaces. The evidences demonstrate that the change after the redesign of budgetary policy in the context of redemocratization occurs gradually with the influence of two ideational mechanisms acting under the process of change in the CMO, these being the public philosophy and the decisional control mechanism, in addition, the coexistence between these two ideational mechanisms brings inaccurate institutional results, with an emptying of the CMO's planning action.
     
4
  • Adelmar de Miranda Tôrres
  • Three empirical essays on the decision-making behavior of the Brazilian Supreme Court.

  • Advisor : PABLO HOLMES CHAVES
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • CIRO CAMPOS CHRISTO FERNANDES
  • ALEXANDRE ARAUJO COSTA
  • CARLOS AUGUSTO MELLO MACHADO
  • FREDERICO BERTHOLINI SANTOS RODRIGUES
  • Luiz Alberto dos Santos
  • PABLO HOLMES CHAVES
  • Data: Apr 22, 2024


  • Show Abstract
  • This research aims to investigate the judicial behavior of the Brazilian Supreme Federal Court (STF), which unfolds into three independent essays outlined in chapters 1, 2, and 3. The methodological approach adopted in this study is multifaceted, integrating both qualitative and quantitative techniques to provide a comprehensive understanding of the judicial performance of the STF. In the first chapter, an analysis of the STF's response to populism and authoritarianism in the Bolsonaro government was conducted, emphasizing the imperative need for democratic institutions to exert effective restraint against this threat. Through descriptive analysis, three emblematic cases from 2019 and 2020 were explored, including decisions related to the COVID-19 pandemic and controversial presidential manifestations. The study utilized the Qualitative Comparative Analysis (QCA) methodology to identify the determining variables behind these STF decisions. The results of this chapter revealed how the clash between Bolsonaro's populism and the STF influenced the court's decisions, highlighting its role as a barrier to right-wing populism, which corroborates aspects discussed in the literature review. Furthermore, the application of the QCA methodology allowed for the identification of the reasons behind the STF's anti-populist behavior, emphasizing the importance of political, ideological, and social dimensions. The second chapter investigates the relationship between the STF's decision-making behavior and the party coalitions in the Bolsonaro government, focusing on concentrated control actions related to federal laws from 2019 to 2022. The study, using a logistic model, analyzes how the strength of government coalitions influences the counter-majoritarian behavior of the STF, confirming the hypothesis that judicial independence is maximized in scenarios of political fragmentation. The results indicate a significant reduction in the probability of counter-majoritarian decisions by the STF with the strengthening of government coalitions, particularly evidenced by the alliance with the “Centrão”. Specifically, the probability of a counter-majoritarian decision by the court decreased by 86% following Bolsonaro's alliance with the “Centrão” in 2021. The third chapter is dedicated to an empirical analysis of the deference of the STF to the Public Treasury in tax cases judged under the General Repercussion from 2008 to 2023. The study employed exploratory descriptive analysis, logistic regression, and Item Response Theory (IRT) modeling techniques in addition to a literature review. The results reveal that the STF ruled in favor of the Public Treasury in approximately 59% of cases, especially when it is the defendant in the dispute. Through IRT analysis, a more pronounced deference to the Public Treasury was observed by Justices Alexandre de Moraes, Dias Toffoli, and Gilmar Mendes, while Justices Edson Fachin and Roberto Barroso demonstrated a more moderate deference. It was also seen that the STF is 86% more likely to show respect for the Public Treasury when it is the defendant in the dispute, when contributions are at issue, when the presiding minister has worked in the Federal Executive Branch before, and when the ruler leans to the center-right. The thesis at the end unifies the findings of the chapters under the guiding thread of the STF's clashes with presidential powers, through elements of the constitutional court's decision-making behavior.
     
5
  • Maria Stella Martins Silva D'Agostini
  • Germinal Marxisms

  • Advisor : LUIS FELIPE MIGUEL
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • ANGÉLICA LOVATTO
  • JUAREZ ROCHA GUIMARÃES
  • LUIS FELIPE MIGUEL
  • STEFAN FORNOS KLEIN
  • THIAGO APARECIDO TRINDADE
  • Data: May 6, 2024


  • Show Abstract
  • Revisiting several authors who developed their analyses of Latin America throughout the twentieth century, this work searches in their respective theoretical propositions the categorization of Latin American Marxisms as from the periphery or on the periphery of capitalism. Thus, from a critical analysis concentrate on the aspects of dialectical logic and the historical materialist method, the objective is to define the frontiers between what Latin America has produced about itself from the instrumentalization of a method or their application of an analytical model. Therefore, at the end of this research it will be possible to understand the weight of this course of analysis choice both for what is understood as a historical process – and revolutionary, also – for the deeply varied Latin American Marxist interpretations. Furthermore, the purpose includes fostering the debate about the focal particular elements that delimit the two categories and how they are pertinent to the perspective of the analytical protagonism of the periphery of capitalism as the formulator of its own theoretical and revolutionary proposals.
     
6
  • LARA CALDAS FERNANDES DA SILVEIRA
  • Neoliberal Ideology and the Urban: Dedemocratization from Private Autonomous Territories.
  • Advisor : THIAGO APARECIDO TRINDADE
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • THIAGO APARECIDO TRINDADE
  • FLAVIA MILLENA BIROLI TOKARSKI
  • LUIS FELIPE MIGUEL
  • RAYANI MARIANO DOS SANTOS
  • SIMONE TULUMELLO
  • Data: May 28, 2024


  • Show Abstract
  • This thesis explores the relationship between a current trend towards extreme privatization of urban areas and de-democratization under neoliberalism in the Brazilian context. This is done through two theoretical axes and an instrumental case study. The first theoretical axis is developed on the social production of urban space and social imaginaries; and the second, on neoliberalism and the crisis of democracy. The case study chosen was the 'first private neighborhood in Porto Alegre', Golden Lake, owned by Multiplan. The central argument is that, as part of an anti-democratic neoliberal political project, a radical form of urbanization is emerging, characterized by an enormous volume of socio-spatial privatization that imagines territories that are increasingly autonomous and unaccountable in relation to their external world. I call this emerging phenomenon 'Private Semi-Autonomous Territories' (PST). As a backdrop, I explore the relationship between society ideations and urban imaginaries, departing from Lefebvrian theory that urban space, from its conception, is imminently political.
     
7
  • Hesaú Rômulo Braga Pinto
  • Stretching Representation? An analysis of the inclusion of ethnic groups in Latin American representative institutions.

  • Advisor : ADRIAN NICOLAS ALBALA YOUNG
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • ADRIAN NICOLAS ALBALA YOUNG
  • FREDERICO BERTHOLINI SANTOS RODRIGUES
  • MARISA VON BULOW
  • GERMÁN BIDEGAIN PONTE
  • VITOR TOKICHEN TRICOT
  • Data: May 31, 2024


  • Show Abstract
  • The issue of the inclusion of ethnic demands has been analyzed from different perspectives in recent years. This work seeks to break the intellectual monopoly on the explanatory keys surrounding indigenous representation in Latin America, by offering political science's own mechanisms for analyzing how the phenomenon of the inclusion of ethnic demands has taken place in some countries in the region and others that have not. In order to carry out this academic endeavor, comparative politics was used, especially the QCA as a methodological and analytical tool to understand what forms indigenous representation can take in different countries. By selecting 10 countries (Argentina, Brazil, Bolivia, Chile, Colombia, Ecuador, Guatemala, Mexico, Paraguay and Peru) we sought to investigate the causal mechanisms of indigenous representation. Despite the creation of four research variables, it is possible to affirm that the occurrence of the phenomenon in the region is associated with the consolidation and cohesiveness of social movements, but mainly with the presence of ethnic parties that activate symbols of resistance. The findings of this thesis contribute to broadening the research agenda of Latin American political science.

8
  • Karen de Oliveira Silverwood-Cope
  • THE GOVERNMENT DECISION-MAKING PROCESS OF NATIONAL POLICY ON CLIMATE CHANGE
  • Advisor : PAULO CARLOS DU PIN CALMON
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • GUARANY IPÊ DO SOL OSORIO
  • André Luiz Campos de Andrade
  • MAURO GUILHERME MAIDANA CAPPELLARO
  • PAULO CARLOS DU PIN CALMON
  • SUELY MARA VAZ GUIMARÃES DE ARAÚJO
  • Data: Jun 21, 2024


  • Show Abstract
  • This project refers to agenda setting situated in the field of public policies agenda setting. The object of study is the agenda setting of the National Climate Change Policy. The general objective of the research is to apply the Multiple Streams Model, proposed by Kingdon (2011), in an investigation of causal mechanisms of the agenda setting of the instruments for the implementation of the National Policy on Climate Change (PNMC). The investigation assumes that the casual mechanisms were triggered by the convergence of the streams with an operating policy entrepreneur. The empirical research is applied with the method of process tracing, with qualitative research and content analysis on data collected through documentary research and interviews with key informants. The results indicate that a government agenda was heterogeneous across the period and between the areas of action plan, monitoring, and financing of the National Climate Change Policy. Three different periods were identified in the National Climate Change Policy, determined by central events: the first period, from 2009 to 2103, consists of the emergence of the policy, with the advent of the Law and formulation of sectoral plans; the second period, from 2014 to 2018, was marked by the formulation of the National Determined Contribution (NDC) of the Paris Agreement of the United Nations Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC), and the third period, from 2019- 2020 was marked by the rise of a conservative government that denies climate change and the COVID 19 pandemic. Across periods, international influence was decisive in the formation of streams. The causal mechanisms for agenda setting were the interest of actors in obtaining international resources, whether through international cooperation projects or market mechanisms and to ensure visibility and reputational projection in multilateral environmental forums. Institutions, mainly international, had a stabilizing influence on the agenda setting. This influence balanced the unpredictability and uncertainty of the national context, allowing windows of opportunity for agenda setting and decision-making processes.

9
  • MAX STABILE MENDES
  • Google and the Brazilian Elections

  • Advisor : MARISA VON BULOW
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • LUCIANA FERNANDES VEIGA
  • ERNESTO CALVO
  • MARISA VON BULOW
  • MATHIEU TURGEON
  • REBECCA NEAERA ABERS
  • Data: Jun 21, 2024


  • Show Abstract
  • This thesis investigates the role of Google in the Brazilian elections of 2020, focusing on the mediation of political information in a subnational election. The study was conducted with a methodological approach that combines: quantitative analysis of 518,000 search results (SERP - Search Engine Results Page), collected between August and November 2020 in a sample of Brazilian municipalities; two rounds of longitudinal panel surveys with 2,771 individuals, representative of the Brazilian population (before and after the elections); and the collection of the search history of some of the respondents. This work answers for whom, how, and when Google is relevant in elections, maps the main sites displayed for different search terms, and, through a “quasi-experiment,” assesses the existence of interference by Google in search results at the start of the electoral period. The results indicate that voters with strong political preferences are the ones who most frequently conduct political-electoral searches, challenging the Search Engine Manipulation Effect hypothesis; show that Google is crucial for accessing information about candidates, especially in the last three days before the election; highlight that 10 sites accounted for 60% of the political-electoral search results during the period; and suggest signs of possible Google interference at the beginning of the electoral period.

2023
Dissertations
1
  • NAYRA THAMIRES ALVES RAMOS
  • Women of the Right: Conservatisms and their Representations in Parliament

  • Advisor : DANUSA MARQUES
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • DANUSA MARQUES
  • CARLOS AUGUSTO MELLO MACHADO
  • FLAVIA MILLENA BIROLI TOKARSKI
  • DENISE MARIA MANTOVANI
  • Data: Mar 16, 2023


  • Show Abstract
  • In this work, I try to understand how the women elected by right-wing parties of the national legislature build what should be represented, that is, the question that guides this work is: how the parliamentarians of right-wing parties of the 56th Legislature mobilize a meaning for the construction what would be the female interest within your legislatures? For this, I analyze the legislative proposals presented by deputies of the 56th Legislature of the Chamber of Deputies from right-wing parties that allude to women's needs and interests. The results indicate that there is a difference between direct women, making it possible to classify them between conservative and neoconservative, in addition to pointing out violence as an important issue for women. Using Critical Discourse Analysis, it was possible to determine which senses are used to determine female interest within the perspective of right-wing women.

2
  • TÚLIO PUSTRELO CELINI
  • The meanings of democracy and freedom in dispute in contemporary Brazil: an analysisbased on the speeches and official pronouncements of Jair Bolsonaro (2019-2022)

  • Advisor : LUIS FELIPE MIGUEL
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • LUIS FELIPE MIGUEL
  • THIAGO APARECIDO TRINDADE
  • DEBORA MESSENBERG GUIMARAES
  • RICARDO MUSSE
  • Data: Mar 27, 2023


  • Show Abstract
  • This dissertation aims to investigate the main meanings attributed to the terms “democracy”and “freedom” by Jair Bolsonaro, during the period in which he was president (2019-2022).Thereunto, the work performs a qualitative content analysis of the 326 speeches and officialpronouncements given by the then President of the Republic, between 2019 and 2022, whichmentioned the words “democracy” and/or “freedom”.

3
  • Cristian Jesus da Silva
  • Nationalized Parties are More Disciplined? The case of Brazil
     
  • Advisor : ANDRE BORGES DE CARVALHO
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • ADRIAN NICOLAS ALBALA YOUNG
  • ANDRE BORGES DE CARVALHO
  • FREDERICO BERTHOLINI SANTOS RODRIGUES
  • PEDRO JOSE FLORIANO RIBEIRO
  • Data: May 30, 2023


  • Show Abstract
  • This dissertation investigates the effects of party nationalization on the legislative behavior of parties
    legislative behavior of parties in presidential systems in Latin America. The literature believes that
    the level of nationalization has an important effect on some policy factors, such as legislative behavior
    legislative behavior, public policy choice, and the relationship between the government and the presidential
    and the presidential coalition. Some papers draw attention to the importance of understanding the vertical
    the vertical dimension of nationalization, especially in multi-level systems where the regional sphere of
    regional politics plays an important role in the dynamics of presidential systems in the region and
    region and allows for a wide range of party strategies in electoral competition. O
    objective of this study is to analyze whether nationalized strategies, with a high level of vertical integration
    vertical integration among party branches, result in high levels of discipline of party behavior.
    behavior. The analysis of the Brazilian case allows us to understand this causal relationship in a decentralized
    decentralized political system, where electoral institutions provoke incongruent incentives in party strategies.
    party strategies.

4
  • Iris Leonhardt Pavan
  • URBAN SEGREGATION AND THE SEXUAL DIVISION OF LABOR: AN INTERSECTIONAL VIEW ON THE DAILY REPRODUCTION OF INEQUALITIES IN BRASÍLIA

  • Advisor : THIAGO APARECIDO TRINDADE
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • CARLOS AUGUSTO MELLO MACHADO
  • DANUSA MARQUES
  • JULIANA MACHADO COELHO
  • THIAGO APARECIDO TRINDADE
  • Data: Jun 29, 2023


  • Show Abstract
  • As a structural element of the capitalist city, urban segregation impacts a series of processes that shape and strongly condition everyday life. Likewise, the sexual division of labor influences and structures the organization possibilities of individuals depending on gender, class and race. Both influence access to free time. Considering that domestic work, for which women are mostly responsible, is also carried out outside the home, in the city, the dissertation analyzes the relationship between sexual division of labor and urban segregation. It is argued that there is an expression of the former in space and that both phenomena add up to create more everyday barriers for women, especially black and poor women. In order to understand how it is structured and what are the impacts of this city configuration, this work focuses on the case of Ceilândia, in the Federal District, which arises from an eradication of invasions of the utopian modernist capital. First, it discusses how Brasília's urban project aimed to reflect a more modern country, but the role of the State and the market led the new capital to become one of the most segregated, androcentric and racist cities in Brazil. Afterwards, interviews with the pioneer residents of Ceilândia, collected by the Federal District archive, were analyzed, with a focus on the elements that configure the socio-spatial dimension of the sexual division of labor - proximity of the house to collective equipment, mobility, access to infrastructure and urban ambience. From them, there was a collection of data from the PDAD and the Social Vulnerability Index, which link the stories told by the pioneers with the consequences and difficulties experienced in the present by the city's residents.

5
  • Lucas Almeida Couto
  • Pre-Electoral Coalitions and Government Formation in Presidentialism

  • Advisor : ADRIAN NICOLAS ALBALA YOUNG
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • ADRIAN NICOLAS ALBALA YOUNG
  • ANDRE BORGES DE CARVALHO
  • FREDERICO BERTHOLINI SANTOS RODRIGUES
  • RAIMONDAS IBENSKAS
  • Data: Jul 18, 2023


  • Show Abstract
  • This dissertation assesses which conditions enable the transition of pre-electoral coalitions into coalition governments in Latin American presidential regimes through a multimethod research design. Even though most literature praises the fact that pre-electoral coalitions exert a non-negligible impact on government formation in presidentialism, I present a nuance to this relationship by arguing that pre-electoral coalitions are not automatically transformed into coalition cabinets in presidentialism. This is so because of the nature of presidential institutions, which grants presidents the opportunity to revise the pre-electoral agreement once they hold office at the same time that diminishes the extent to which pre-electoral coalition members can punish them. Against this backdrop, the first empirical paper puts forward and tests the claim that pre-electoral pacts should be more binding to the extent that legislative polarisation is more pervasive in the party system. The reason is that an increased ideological dividedness at the party system level reduces presidents’ margins to build coalition cabinets not based on the pre-electoral pact, as complexity bargaining hampers the presidential ability to assemble parties with conflicting policy preferences in the same cabinet. In addition, based on a configurational rationale, the second empirical paper investigates what makes pre-electoral coalitions serve as the foundations of post-electoral coalition cabinets, given that pre-electoral commitments can be enlarged, maintained or shrunk until the government’s inauguration day. The results highlight the importance of five conditions, albeit with more prominence for the pre-electoral coalition majority status, the low polarisation between pre-electoral coalition members and the high legislative polarisation. Taken together, the findings of this dissertation enlarge our knowledge of the relationship between pre-electoral coalitions and government formation in presidentialism by showing its entanglement with legislative polarisation.

6
  • João Victor Barbosa Ferreira
  • Political Radicalization and Youth in Brazil: The Formation of Collective Identity through Gamer Communities on Discord

  • Advisor : MARISA VON BULOW
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • MARISA VON BULOW
  • DEBORA CRISTINA REZENDE DE ALMEIDA
  • REBECCA NEAERA ABERS
  • ROSANA PINHEIRO MACHADO
  • Data: Aug 1, 2023


  • Show Abstract
  • The Internet and digital media have become social spaces for exchange and interaction among actors and groups with significant impact on the contemporary world. Since the beginning of the 2010s, social scientists have identified roots of a toxic technoculture based on prejudice, reactionary views, and intolerance within gamer subculture. This, combined with other factors, has led to the development of anti-video game activism and a stigmatized public opinion about electronic games, which are seen as potential inducers of violent and antisocial behavior. As a result, the gamer community has distanced itself from traditional social spaces and congregated first on chans and image boards, and later, with the advancement of big tech, in virtual spaces through applications that allow the prefiguration of alternative societies. The dichotomy between public opinion and gamer identity has created a context of polarization and aversion, with the latter contributing to the consolidation of anti-system activism.

    Especially after the election of far-right leaders around the globe, gamer communities have been investigated as chambers for the reproduction of extremist ideologies. In this context, the present research aims to understand the process of political mobilization among young people in digital spaces populated by gamer subcultures, in order to answer which worldviews, repertoires, and political practices permeate these communities on Discord in Brazil. Through a longitudinal ethnographic approach, the collected data spans a period of nearly 3 years (2020-2023) within the three largest organized public groups on the aforementioned application.

    Empirical analysis confirms that the gamer community and subculture are diverse and plural, although a state of hegemony prevails in discourses and positions of power. This leads to the production and circulation of extremist and intolerant content, which is masked through memetic techniques to appear humorous and be more accepted by members. Simultaneously, insiders develop their own symbols and communicative expressions, whose meaning is not intelligible to non-initiates. Drawing on the concept of encrypted activism, the research demonstrates the existence of communication flows for the transmission of reactionary and intolerant syntagms, which are masked to be read and discovered only by those familiar with the way. Through Discord, materials produced by YouTubers, websites, blogs, and content creators (influencers) circulate, working to spread far-right ideologies among young video game players in the Brazil.
     
7
  • Igor da Silva Brito
  • Expansion of the Presidential Center as a Response to Agency Risk: A Comparative Analysis of Coalition Cabinets in Latin America

  • Advisor : ADRIAN NICOLAS ALBALA YOUNG
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • ADRIAN NICOLAS ALBALA YOUNG
  • ANDRE BORGES DE CARVALHO
  • LUCIO REMUZAT RENNO JUNIOR
  • MAGNA MARIA INÁCIO
  • Data: Sep 5, 2023


  • Show Abstract
  • The purpose of this work is to explain the size variation of the presidential center in coalition governments in Latin America. The presidential center is the bulk of administrative units directly subordinate to the president and that is officially part of the Presidency of the Republic, performing functions that reinforce presidential power. The main argument developed here is that the president faces a trade-off regarding to presidential center, with incentives to expand it to deal with agency risk arising from divergent preferences among actors within the Executive Branch. The unfolded hypotheses of this argument were tested with data of Argentina, Brazil, Colombia, and Uruguay through linear regression models for panel data. The results show that ideological amplitude of coalition on government has a positive and statistically significant effect on the presidential center size, but no evidence was found to support the hypotheses of presidential ideological extremism and degree of cabinet partisanship.

8
  • Felipe Augusto Torres de Carvalho
  • ANALYSIS OF CARBON PRICING INITIATIVES IN BRAZIL IN THE LIGHT OF THE COMMON POOL RESOURCES GOVERNANCE THEORY

  • Advisor : FREDERICO BERTHOLINI SANTOS RODRIGUES
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • FREDERICO BERTHOLINI SANTOS RODRIGUES
  • PAULO CARLOS DU PIN CALMON
  • RONALDO SEROA DA MOTTA
  • SUELY MARA VAZ GUIMARÃES DE ARAÚJO
  • Data: Sep 26, 2023


  • Show Abstract
  • This work applies Elinor Ostrom's theory of common-pool resource governance to evaluate policy proposals for the implementation of a carbon pricing instrument in Brazil, notably the Presidential Decree 11.075/2022, and Bills 2148/2015 and 412/2022 from the House of Representatives and the Federal Senate, respectively. Through content analysis, the aim is to understand whether these regulatory proposals adhere to the design principles for good management of common-pool resources and whether the analysis from this perspective can provide recommendations for improving the mentioned legislative proposals. Additionally, the work seeks to map the background of the debate on GHG pricing in Brazil, highlighting the national and international context, initiatives, and actors that have driven the discussion on the topic in the country. In this effort, special attention is given to the development of the PMR Project, the main catalyst for this debate in the Brazilian context, with the goal of understanding the origins of the partnership, objectives, engaged players, project outcomes, recommendations made, and their application in the three aforementioned policy proposals. The study concludes that few of Ostrom's design principles are fully observed in the legislative proposals under discussion in Brazil. Furthermore, gaps were identified in the regulations studied that hinder their compliance with the principles, such as the exclusion of sectors of the economy from the regulated carbon market proposed by the three norms, the absence of conflict resolution mechanisms among the regulated sectors, and the lack of the possibility of applying rules through nested organizations at different levels. These gaps provide input for reflection on potential recommendations to improve the proposals under study. Regarding the mapping of the carbon pricing debate in Brazil, it was concluded that the private sector has had - and still has - a strong influence and presence, particularly within the PMR Project. Entities such as CEBDS, the Brazil Climate, Forests, and Agriculture Coalition, and the CNI played a fundamental role as drivers of the discussion. As for the results of the PMR Project itself, it was found that it deemed it desirable for Brazil to adopt an Emissions Trading System (ETS) and provided recommendations on the characteristics that such a system should have. Finally, this work has highlighted that the bill most aligned with the recommendations made by the Project is the Bill 2148/2015, which fully or partially meets all the suggestions raised.
     
9
  • Matheus Baccarin Pereira
  • "It's not about the vaccine, it's about freedom": The activism against the compulsory vaccination for COVID-19 in Brazil

  • Advisor : MARISA VON BULOW
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • MARISA VON BULOW
  • MICHELLE VIEIRA FERNANDEZ DE OLIVEIRA
  • REBECCA NEAERA ABERS
  • RAQUEL DA CUNHA RECUERO
  • Data: Dec 15, 2023


  • Show Abstract
  • The COVID-19 pandemic was a politicized and contentious event, which made explicit ideological divisions between the radical right and progressives that existed before the health crisis. In Brazil, former president Jair Bolsonaro, a radical right populist, made several speeches attacking the COVID-19 vaccines, which fueled an unusual activism against mandatory vaccines and childhood vaccination in the country. This dissertation is guided by the following research question: what is the connection between right-wing political ideologies and activism against mandatory COVID-19 vaccination in Brazil? The general aim of the research is to understand how right-wing ideologies have been linked to the movement to challenge mandatory COVID-19 vaccination in Brazil. Specifically, we analyzed the forms of discursive legitimation and the construction of collective action frames. The research has a qualitative design based on 42 semi-structured interviews with parliamentarians and activists and 5 participant observations, in 2 online courses and in 3 face-to-face protests. Through this effort, we sought to analyze the interpretive frames and collective action strategies of activists opposed to mandatory vaccination for COVID-19. As a result, we found in the discourses a strong ideological homogeneity to the right and an identity construction that strategically rejects "anti-vaccine", "anti-science" and "denialists" labels.

10
  • Luiza Aikawa da Silveira Rocha
  • Coalitions in proportional elections and candidate strategy: observing the (de)nationalization of Brazilian parties

  • Advisor : CARLOS AUGUSTO MELLO MACHADO
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • CARLOS AUGUSTO MELLO MACHADO
  • DANUSA MARQUES
  • PEDRO JOSE FLORIANO RIBEIRO
  • THIAGO APARECIDO TRINDADE
  • Data: Dec 18, 2023


  • Show Abstract
  • In this dissertation, we are guided by the question of how changes in electoral norms can impact the strategies of electoral participation for political parties. The reform implemented in 2020 put an end to coalitions in proportional elections and had as one of its objectives the reduction of political parties in Brazil. Our main objective is to observe if, between the elections of 2000 and 2020, parties behaved in a more nationalized way depending on the current rules. More specifically, we seek to analyze their presence in electoral districts and the patterns of participation in all of the elections from the period. We found that in 2020 there was a significant territorial retraction in party participation for municipal elections in Brazil, indicating a process of denationalization.

11
  • Júlia Matravolgyi Damião
  • COOPERATION AND DEMOCRACY: EVERYDAY CARE RELATIONSHIPS AND WOMEN’S PUBLIC PARTICIPATION

  • Advisor : FLAVIA MILLENA BIROLI TOKARSKI
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • FLAVIA MILLENA BIROLI TOKARSKI
  • MICHELLE VIEIRA FERNANDEZ DE OLIVEIRA
  • LAYLA DANIELE PEDREIRA DE CARVALHO
  • MARIANA MAZZINI MARCONDES
  • Data: Dec 18, 2023


  • Show Abstract
  • Care, a social practice composed of relationships of interdependence to meet concrete, emotional and psychological needs, it’s a collective need and, at certain stages of existence, is the defining condition of an individual (GUIMARÃES, 2021). As care is inevitable, thus there is always a someone in charge of its execution: this burden usually falls on families and, within them, on women. However, its universal nature prevents care from being the exclusive responsibility of a certain group without this generating distorted dynamics of isolation for those responsible. The family is in direct interaction with and under the reciprocal influence of other institutions. Regarding care needs, these entities have in women's actions what Faur (2014) calls a “non-explicit assumption”, that is, both the market and public services are structured assuming that they, silently and invisible, will meet the demand for care discovered by social structures. This is especially true in extremely unequal societies, in which the State and market do not reach the needs of parts of the population and, due to their absence, are structuring of a type of care inserted in the poorest neighborhoods: community care. Such connections originate in contexts in which there are no resources to purchase services on the market (such as hiring a nanny), nor public policies (such as daycare centers) to meet needs (GUIMARÃES, 2019). These exchanges can be delimited by the concept of "care as help", by Guimarães (2021). It defines connections based on the strength of neighborhood networks that have reciprocity as the main (although not exclusive) currency of exchange. These bonds, in general, assume their own logic of retribution and solidarity, including the transgression of traditional concepts of family and the creation of particular power dynamics (MORENO, 2019; FAUR, 2014). Instigated by these considerations, the research developed in this work explores women's perception of the care demands present in their routines, including neighborhood exchanges as significant instances for reflection on the relationship between care and democracy.
     
12
  • ARYELL CALMON GONZAGA BORGES
  • IT RUN IN THE FAMILY: HOW FAMILY CAPITAL RELATED BAHIAN POLITICS

  • Advisor : DANUSA MARQUES
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • DANUSA MARQUES
  • CARLOS AUGUSTO MELLO MACHADO
  • MARISA VON BULOW
  • JOSÉ MARCIANO MONTEIRO
  • Data: Dec 19, 2023


  • Show Abstract
  • This work seeks to apply the concept of political-family capital using the Social Network Analysis (SNA) technique in a mapping in the state of Bahia, identifying, especially, the Magalhães family. Although the theme of the presence of families with political power is not a recent phenomenon, nor has it been interrupted, contemporary political science and sociology have stopped including the family variable in their investigations that seek to understand and explain the political-social structure of Brazil. Here, under the hypotheses that political families perpetuate themselves in power once they occupy this space and that they take root in political institutions in the three powers of the Republic, the central question is how the sharing of political-family capital relates to Bahian politics. In an attempt to understand how the sharing of political-family capital affects local dynamics, we chose to map political families and Carlism in Bahia. This work combines qualitative and quantitative methods to conclude that the individuals investigated make up a group that is not very dense, but with a high level of cluster formation, that is, family clans. Furthermore, it is possible to identify that the network of political-family capital reaches several institutions in the three spheres of power of the Republic and spend, on average, more than six decades in power.

13
  • Vidda Guzzo Faustino
  • I am your glitch": Intersex Activism in Brazil [2006-2021]

  • Advisor : DEBORA CRISTINA REZENDE DE ALMEIDA
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • PAULA SANDRINE MACHADO
  • DEBORA CRISTINA REZENDE DE ALMEIDA
  • MARISA VON BULOW
  • REBECCA NEAERA ABERS
  • Data: Dec 20, 2023


  • Show Abstract
  • Individuals born with congenital variations of sex characteristics consistently experience human rights abuses and violations. Globally, there is a growing network of activism dedicated to safeguarding and advocating for the human rights of intersex communities. This research constitutes a case study on the trajectory of intersex activism in Brazil from 2006 to 2021, with the primary goal of scrutinizing its practices and ideologies. The study contributes significantly to the discourse on political action in Brazil, adding depth to the research agenda on LGBTI activism overall and specifically addressing intersex issues. Furthermore, it aligns with empirical studies within the realms of intersex and gender studies, as well as social movements and political action studies, employing pragmatist and discursive institutionalism approaches. The data collection methodology involved conducting interviews guided by semi-structured questionnaires and analyzing relevant documents. The sampling of respondents took into account the centrality and diversity of network actors. Two distinct research instruments were developed for the audience of activists and individuals facing restrictions on public statements. Between May 13th and October 7th, 2021, eighteen interviews were conducted. Socio-historical content analysis was applied to the interviews and documents, revealing pre-indicators and meaning nuclei. The findings of this research illuminate a spectrum of practices and ideas within intersex activism and trace their contingencies over time. The Portuguese-language Organization International Intersex is identified as the initial milestone in intersex political mobilization in Brazil, dating back to 2006. Until 2009, Waléria Torres' posts on the Organization's blog served as a platform for transmitting personal narratives, conveying non-standardized intersex definitions, discussing human rights, crises, depathologization, and emphasizing activism's practical horizons, including the dissemination of evidence-based data and collaboration with researchers. A new mobilization cycle in 2014 utilized Facebook as a central platform for interaction, allowing the sharing of technical information, life experiences, and the coordination of collective initiatives for increased public visibility. By 2017, successful mobilization efforts had brought together a growing network of intersex groups, individuals, and allies, encompassing researchers, doctors, lawyers, family members, and even conservative actors, while the content of their ideas also evolved, adopting biological and matricentric contours amid the turbulent contexts until 2019. In 2020, the disproportionate impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic discouraged the mobilization of intersex activists. In response, remaining actors mobilized emergency funds, supported online solidarity initiatives, maintained dialogue channels within the Judiciary, engaged in collective candidacies and advocacy in local and state legislatures, retained interaction with the Executive in limited socio-state spaces, and focused on LGBTQIAPN+ coalition-building.

Thesis
1
  • Karina Damous Duailibe
  • DO SURVEYS AND PUBLIC OPINION SERVE TO DEMOCRACY?

    ELEMENTS FOR A REFLECTION

  • Advisor : LUIS FELIPE MIGUEL
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • ALESSANDRA ALDE
  • GILBERTO GONCALVES COSTA
  • LIZIANE SOARES GUAZINA
  • LUIS FELIPE MIGUEL
  • THIAGO APARECIDO TRINDADE
  • Data: Feb 23, 2023


  • Show Abstract
  • This doctoral thesis reflects on the relations between surveys and the notion of public opinion. It highlights two aspects: (1) the reconstitution of the historical moment in which surveys become central in the definition of public opinion; (2) the questioning about the democratic premises attributed to both surveys and public opinion. Since the second half of the 18th century, the notion of public opinion had been incorporated into the political vocabulary as a new reality. From the very beginning, it has been linked to the press and the principles of political liberalism. Despite the growing importance it had acquired as a political category of emerging democratic regimes, it has remained shrouded by indetermination, vagueness, opacity and polysemy. When surveys come about, the perspective of measuring public opinion through the aggregation of the opinions of individuals gains centrality, leading to an important change. Praised as democratic devices, surveys have become considered, and widely accepted, as equivalents of public opinion. The implications of this equivalence are profound for the relations between the fields of politics and the media, and for the relationship between who governs and the governed. Electoral media coverage has now become structured based on the use of polls, just as the popularity ratings of the elected by vote have become critical to the exercise of political leadership. Around this new configuration, a whole field of knowledge of public opinion is consolidated - using surveys - to study the political behavior of individuals and democracy itself. The emphasis of the discussion in this thesis converges, then, to the following question: does the notion of public opinion as equivalent to opinion polls represent gains for democracy? In the absence of a consolidated literature based on a more critic perspective, a discussion is presented with the few authors who dedicated themselves to contesting both the equivalence between surveys and public opinion, as well as the democratic postulates of surveys instrument and the notion itself. In conclusion, the argument is for the constitutive fragility of the democratic assumptions of both, which requires greater scrutiny on the use of surveys by the press as an equivalent of public opinion. On the other hand, it is not a question of arguing for the social irrelevance of surveys, especially before the complexity of opinion movements generated in the online environment, and the anti-research rhetoric from the far-right political spectrum. Regarding to public opinion, the point is that it could serve democracy more if the voices and social groups that effectively influence the sphere of political power do not shelter themselves under the opacity and contradictions that the notion of public opinion carries with it.

2
  • Maria Stela Reis
  • Intersectoral mobility strategies: the Public Policies and Governmental Managerial Specialists (PPGMS) in the Federal Public Administration of Brazil (2000-2018)

  • Advisor : REBECCA NEAERA ABERS
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • REBECCA NEAERA ABERS
  • DEBORA CRISTINA REZENDE DE ALMEIDA
  • SUELY MARA VAZ GUIMARÃES DE ARAÚJO
  • MIGUEL LOUREIRO
  • ROBERTO ROCHA COELHO PIRES
  • Data: Mar 1, 2023


  • Show Abstract
  • With the aim of verifying whether the intersectoral mobility of members of the Specialist in Public Policy and Government Management career led these professionals to act as agents of change through public policies in the Brazilian federal government, this thesis presents a mapping of the individual trajectories between bodies and between positions in commission, the so-called managers in the historical period that includes six presidential terms (2000 to 2018), identifying similarities between them, which can be understood as patterns, grouped in clusters. It was found that approximately 50% of the trajectories are characterized by high mobility. Under the lens of the theory of fields of strategic action by Fligstein & McAdam (2012), the approach to careers elaborated by Schneider (1994) and Bourdieu's concepts of campus and capital in the works of Savage (2005) and Rosssier (2020 ), the movement mechanisms, accumulated capital and calculations for the construction of trajectories in their various contexts and contingencies were analyzed. Within a broader view, it can be said that the equity of this generalist profile is associated with the political technical profile, because at the same time that this professional has the technical capacity and knowledge of some sectoral languages to solve problems, at the same time he manages to make a political reading of the projects and problems in a pragmatic way. Mobility is useful for these strategies of technical-political “being”. It is a useful instrument for public administration, which gives new managers the possibility of forming teams with qualified and experienced professionals, as well as a useful instrument for managers to manage their professional course and, yes, contribute to changes resulting from the public policies which participate. Managers who have a trajectory with a greater number of movements end up revealing a more pronounced political profile, accumulating more capital and being able to act as strategic actors in their fields of action. Contrary to the bureaucratic tradition that values the specialty as a great ability of the administration, as well as sectorial knowledge in the field of public policies, the contribution of the EPPGG is precisely in its intersectoral mobility.

3
  • Leticia Beccalli Klug
  • Determinants of Urban Policy Diffusion in Brazil

  • Advisor : DENILSON BANDEIRA COELHO
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • CARLOS AURÉLIO PIMENTA DE FARIA
  • CECILIA OSORIO GONNET
  • DENILSON BANDEIRA COELHO
  • FREDERICO BERTHOLINI SANTOS RODRIGUES
  • JULIANA BETINI FACHINI GOMES
  • Data: Mar 15, 2023


  • Show Abstract
  • The diffusion of public policies is a growing field of Political Science in Brazil. Research
    that aims to identify why and how public policies diffuse in federative contexts helps to
    understand issues from political behavior and the role of institutions to broader
    processes of multiple agendas, formulation and adoption of public policies. This thesis
    innovates and contributes to the effort by explaining why two urban policy instruments
    - the Outorga Onerosa do Direito de Construir and the Zonas Especiais de Interesse
    Social - have spread among Brazilian municipalities. With a multi-method research
    design, we applied an event history analysis model (Cox’s proportional hazards
    regression) to estimate the hazard rate for policy adoption among 5570 cities. We also
    applied a comparative technique to understand the impact of federal institutions over
    both diffusion processes. Hypotheses about the influence of electoral dynamics, political
    parties, state capacities, socioeconomic conditions just as geographical proximity,
    neighborhood and national interaction were tested. We find evidence that political
    competition, state capacities and regions drive the urban policy diffusion in local
    governments in Brazil.

4
  • Geniana Gazotto Ferreira
  • Studies on the Dysfunctional Creation of Metropolitan Regions in Brazil

  • Advisor : DENILSON BANDEIRA COELHO
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • DENILSON BANDEIRA COELHO
  • PAULO CARLOS DU PIN CALMON
  • REBECCA NEAERA ABERS
  • ANTONIO SERGIO ARAUJO FERNANDES
  • PEDRO LUIZ COSTA CAVALCANTE
  • Data: Mar 27, 2023


  • Show Abstract
  • This research was about policy diffusion with an empirical focus on Brazilian metropolitan regions. The objective was to investigate the conformation and dynamics of metropolitan regions, seeking to understand the political, economic and social factors that influence diffusion. The thesis seeks to contribute to the discussion of the policy diffusion process and the Brazilian federative design. In this context, two research questions guided this study: What is the structure and dynamics of the metropolitan regions diffusion in the Brazil? What political, economic and social benefits are related to the institutionalization of these metropolitan regions? The diffusion process was analysed in general, with a survey and analysis of an extensive set of data on the metropolitan regions in Brazil and through four case studies, referring to the states of Alagoas, Paraíba, Paraná and Santa Catarina. To carry out the case studies, a qualitative research method was used with the collection and analysis of documentary research, semi-structured interviews with key informants, cartographic elaboration and investigation of state complementary laws. The analysis of the case studies was based on political, economic and social factors that influenced the metropolitan regions diffusion process. For the selected cases, research variables were developed and three hypotheses were tested. The results showed that the studied cases became more likely to create metropolitan regions based on characteristics of greater geographic proximity, influence of regional political agents and increase in transfers of resources from federal programs. In addition, the diffusion process of metropolitan regions creation did not accompany the development of adequate functional and bureaucratic management structures. Several metropolitan regions were created that do not have technical criteria or management instruments, such as metropolitan companies, participatory councils and financing funds. In this way, there was institutionalization by complementary laws, but there was no actual implementation of these metropolitan regions. The selected cases demonstrated that the metropolitan regions institutionalization was used as a strategy for distinguishing urban spaces in the competition for resources, without the implementation of inter-federative governance in terms of public function of common interest between the federal entities.

5
  • Adriana de Oliveira Pinheiro
  • Legislative and Environmental Licensing in Brazil from a federal perspective.

  • Advisor : CARLOS AUGUSTO MELLO MACHADO
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • CARLOS AUGUSTO MELLO MACHADO
  • DENILSON BANDEIRA COELHO
  • PAULO CARLOS DU PIN CALMON
  • ANA REGINA VILLAR PERES AMARAL
  • Rafael Silveira e Silva
  • Data: Mar 30, 2023


  • Show Abstract
  • Today, there are few recent studies that consider the subnational impact on national legislative processes in Brazil. This thesis seeks to continue the study in the line of research on legislative studies with emphasis in the federative perspective and in the role of subnational governments. This study approaches the parliamentary dynamics in scenario of federative conflicts in matters related to the regulatory basis of environmental policy, in particular environmental licensing, an issue in which the federative conflict is clearly characterized. The selected cases are the process that gave rise to Complementary Law n. 140/2011 and the proposal for the Licensing Law (PLP No. 12/2003 and similar). We sought to understand the negotiation process and which guidelines prevailed throughout the process. Tracking of the legislative process and content analysis of 22 interviews were carried out, with emphasis on the analytical narrative from the perspective of interviewed. The framework was Multiple Streams Model. The results indicate that the Complementary Law was able to solve, in part, the problem about the attributions of entities in licensing. The substitute approved in the Chamber for the General Law presents setbacks in the definition of license procedures. It is highlighted that the role of subnational governments proved to be relevant in the two processes considered.

6
  • Maricilene Isaira Baia Nascimento
  • Creating the Conquest of the Master´s House: A history of the creative political ecology of institutional construction of the National Council of Justice, 1987-2020

  • Advisor : REBECCA NEAERA ABERS
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • DEBORA CRISTINA REZENDE DE ALMEIDA
  • PABLO HOLMES CHAVES
  • REBECCA NEAERA ABERS
  • ROGÉRIO BASTOS ARANTES
  • JOÃO PAULO DOS SANTOS DIAS
  • Data: Apr 12, 2023


  • Show Abstract
  • This thesis is about the story of a great process of institutional construction that I dare to identify

    as “creating the conquest of the Master´s House”. Attributing the 'Master´s House' to a system of
    power in which few have access to the resources and decision-making processes of/in the
    management of the Brazilian judicial public service, I argue that a significant part of the history of
    institutional construction of the National Council of Justice – the administrative and disciplinary
    control body of the Brazilian judiciary – received significative influence from political movements
    of different actors for the democratization of the management and allocation of public resources
    of judiciary, with emphasis on the political movements of the magistracy of first instance, which
    enabled the strengthening of other political movements of different actors in search of
    democratization of the administration of Brazilian justice. In dialogue with pragmatism, I also argue
    that the connection between these different movements has been weaving what I propose to
    conceptualize as “institutional ecology” – a political-creative complex of rules and resources (ideas,
    fields, symbols, processes, actors, and relations), to try to generate a set of democratizing policies
    in the management and allocation of public justice resources. The research covers a long historical
    period (1987-2020) and a diversity of empirical sources, such as (i) observations made at
    institutional events, (ii) observations made during on-site visits to Courts of Justice, (iii) in-depth
    interviews with actors that make up the Justice system, (iv) testimonies of key actors raised by the
    project “Oral History of the CNJ” of the Center for Research and Documentation on
    Contemporary Brazilian History, and (v) intense mobilization of journalistic and institutional
    documents. The descriptive-analytical-historical axis of the thesis is organized into twelve Episodes
    with the scenes played by those movements in the different institutional phases of the CNJ – like
    a constitutional rule, an organization, and a public policy. In addition to bringing to light the
    backstage and the repercussions of the creativity of these movements in the search for the
    democratization of the management of the judicial public service, the story it proposes to tell also
    brings the weaknesses of this search.
     
    Keywords: National Council of Justice; democratization of management and on the allocation of

    justice public resources; prioritization of courts of first instance; action nets; institutional ecology.

7
  • Débora Françolin Quintela
  • A FAMILY'S MINISTRY: FROM GENDER MAINSTREAMING TO THE FAMILIARIZATION OF FEDERAL PUBLIC POLICIES

  • Advisor : FLAVIA MILLENA BIROLI TOKARSKI
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • FLAVIA MILLENA BIROLI TOKARSKI
  • LUIS FELIPE MIGUEL
  • LAYLA DANIELE PEDREIRA DE CARVALHO
  • MAÍRA KUBIK TAVEIRA MANO
  • LUCIANA FERREIRA TATAGIBA
  • Data: May 15, 2023


  • Show Abstract
  • This thesis analyzes the activism against feminism and gender equality in Jair Bolsonaro’s
    government (2019-2022). It investigates how this government, guided by a neoliberal and
    neoconservative political rationality, promoted an agenda of familiarization of public
    policies, based on fostering the traditional family as the basis of society and the
    privatization of responsibilities for the development and survival of individuals centered
    on the family. It also examines how this agenda is connected to the transnational backlash
    against gender. It is detected that the governmentality that emerges from the combination
    between those rationalities is founded on a single, restricted concept of family: the
    traditional (nuclear, patriarchal, referentially white and cisheteronormative), based on
    sexual difference. Thus, it is a kind of familism based on a limiting conception of the
    feminine, reduced to the reproductive function and anchored in the conventional sexual
    division of labor. The empirical analysis of this research was based on extensive desk
    research of the Women, Family and Human Rights’ Ministry (WFHRM), an office which
    mission was to mainstream the (traditional) family perspective. By examining the
    structure, the actors, the use of the budget and the policies implemented, especially, by
    its National Secretary of Policies for Women (NSPW) and National Secretary of the
    Family (NSF), it was identified a reframing of the conception of human rights, which no
    longer focuses on individuals but on the family. Concerning women, however, there was
    a specificity, they were effectively mobilized by the WFHRM as a means to achieve a
    goal: that the family should privately bear all the care needs. This was done so that the
    State could be assigned only the economic and the (re)production of a traditional morality
    functions. This project, it is argued, confronted basic democratic values such as equality,
    plurality, respect for political antagonism, and freedom.

8
  • Júlia Alves Marinho Rodrigues
  • LEGISLATIVE AND INTERTEMPORAL DILEMMAS IN PUBLIC POLICIES: THE CASE OF THE CEILING OF EXPENSES

  • Advisor : PAULO CARLOS DU PIN CALMON
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • ARNALDO MAUERBERG JUNIOR
  • DENILSON BANDEIRA COELHO
  • PAULO CARLOS DU PIN CALMON
  • RITA DE CASSIA LEAL FONSECA DOS SANTOS
  • Rafael Silveira e Silva
  • Data: May 17, 2023


  • Show Abstract
  • The intertemporal dilemmas, i.e., problems that demand integrated and often long-term solutions are characteristic of modern societies. However, in democratic societies, elections require short-term responses. The thesis seeks to investigate under what conditions Parliament is able to approve policy investments¸ i.e., measures in which short-term costs are imposed in the expectation of long-term benefits. For that, a case study was carried out on the procedure, in the Chamber of Deputies and in the Federal Senate, of the Constitutional Amendment nº95, of 2016, which established the New Fiscal Regime and the conditions that allowed its approval were verified. Starting from the analytical model, the conditions that allowed the overcoming of short-term informational biases, long-term political uncertainty and the performance of organized interest groups were examined. Among the main findings of the research, there is the favorable institutional scenario, combining a diffuse responsibility for losses, the low risk for electoral survival as a result of supporting the PEC, insofar as it was a complex topic, with low understanding on the part of society, and strong support from the President of the Republic and parliamentary leaders; a public policy framework that was able to defer short-term costs while anticipating some long-term benefits; and a diffuse distribution of costs that made it difficult to mobilize those most affected and, therefore, the action of interest groups turned to the search for sectoral protection. At the same time, the following elements were pointed out that can contribute to the improvement of the model: consider the internal rules of Parliaments that can facilitate the approval of policy investments; the need to consider, in principle, in middle-income countries the dimension of the medium term when discussing the intertemporal cost-benefit matrix of public policy; the policy learning process that can lead to more workable program structures; and, the sharing of a common diagnosis among the state bureaucracy, facilitating the process of convincing decision-makers.

9
  • Tatiana Whately de Moura
  • Institutional change and activism in Community Councils: towards social participation in the prison system

  • Advisor : DEBORA CRISTINA REZENDE DE ALMEIDA
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • DEBORA CRISTINA REZENDE DE ALMEIDA
  • MARISA VON BULOW
  • REBECCA NEAERA ABERS
  • LUCIANA FERREIRA TATAGIBA
  • ROGÉRIO BASTOS ARANTES
  • Data: Jun 20, 2023


  • Show Abstract
  • Community Councils are established within the Judiciary to oversee prison units and endeavor to obtain material and human resources for the assistance of the incarcerated population. The penal execution law, which established these councils in 1984, left gaps regarding the ways these councils could operate when facing irregularities during visits to prison establishments. This gap allowed the councils to be constituted in various ways, and several guiding materials published over the years expanded the possibilities of action, including a participatory grammar. The objective of the research is to analyze the institutional change of the Community Councils towards a social participation institution. The main hypothesis is that institutional activists worked for a reconfiguration of the Community Councils, mobilized by the participatory ideals that emerged after the 1988 Constitution. The work was based on bibliographic research, extensive documentary research, and semi-structured qualitative interviews with people who participated in the institutional change process between 2000 and 2023 and with community council members. This is a case study of both the institutional change process and the results of this change, based on the analysis of six Community Councils, which, through different practices, demonstrate the advances of socio-state interfaces and the institutional constraints not overcome with the intended institutional change. The thesis analyzes the complete cycle of change, that is, how it changed and what has changed, including its results. To answer the question of how it changed, I present a conceptual map based on pragmatist concepts, focusing on situated action in the context of institutional activism, in which state actors mobilize institutional resources and act strategically in defense of a collectively constructed cause. To understand what has changed, changes are analyzed from both the institutional perspective, considering the new rules established, and their results in practice. The thesis argues that the Community Councils underwent an institutional change process in which institutional activists sought to transform them into participatory forums, but which resulted in a peculiar configuration that expanded, on the one hand, socio-state exchange logics and, on the other hand, the executive functions of these councils, related to a state substitution practice in the provision of goods and services. The results also show an innovative state-society relationship established between the Judiciary, the Executive, and civil society. For more than a decade, civil society, the Executive, and the Judiciary participated in the institutional change process together, mobilizing mainly institutional resources from the Executive, but from 2019 onwards, the leadership in criminal policy shifted from the Executive to the Judiciary, and the National Council of Justice began to lead this process. This triangulation is also observed in the local context of the Community Councils, where both the Executive and the Judiciary can play constraining roles in the actions of the Community Councils or enhance their activities, depending on the understanding these actors have regarding the role of the council and how the council itself can change this understanding.

10
  • Alana Karoline Fontenelle Valente
  • MOBILIZATION OF MATERNITY BY CANDIDATES ON INSTAGRAM (2021-2022)
  • Advisor : LUIS FELIPE MIGUEL
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • LUIS FELIPE MIGUEL
  • FLAVIA MILLENA BIROLI TOKARSKI
  • THIAGO APARECIDO TRINDADE
  • DANILA GENTIL RODRIGUEZ CAL LAGE
  • CAMILO DE OLIVEIRA AGGIO
  • Data: Aug 25, 2023


  • Show Abstract
  • The thesis discusses the use of motherhood as a political resource. It has, as the corpus of analysis, the profiles of eight female candidates running for different positions, from different political parties and states in the Brazilian elections of 2022. Historically, motherhood has been invisible in the public sphere due to women's absence from these spaces. The responsibility of caring for a child seemed incompatible with the full dedication required of a political representative. However, now motherhood is displayed and claimed by many women in politics, which responds to the effort of identifying with the electorate – by sharing an experience common to many women, they show themselves as "people just like us." Often, the discourse also incorporates elements affirming the moral superiority of mothers, associated with altruistic values and care for the vulnerable, approaching the theoretical perspective of the "maternal thinking." However, the visibility of motherhood rarely leads to the presentation of public policy proposals that alleviate the burden on women who are mothers and even less to a demystification of the maternal role. On the contrary, the ideology of reconciling the priority given to mothering, seen as necessary and unquestionable for any woman, with public activity is very present. For the analysis of the empirical material, the thesis relies on the theory of matricentric feminism by Rich and O’Reilly.

11
  • Elisa Vieira Leonel
  • Regulatory pluralism and responsive regulatory culture at Anatel:
    mechanisms and practices in the protection of telecommunications consumer rights.

  • Advisor : PABLO HOLMES CHAVES
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • DENILSON BANDEIRA COELHO
  • Izabela Moreira Correa
  • JOÃO CALDEIRA BRANT MONTEIRO DE CASTRO
  • PABLO HOLMES CHAVES
  • PAULO CARLOS DU PIN CALMON
  • Data: Sep 13, 2023


  • Show Abstract
  • The work seeks to discuss the implementation of regulatory governance anchored on pluralist
    theories of regulation, especially the Responsive Regulation Theory of Ayres and Braithwaite
    (1992), based on the case study on consumer protection in telecommunications. The National
    Telecommunications Agency, along with other regulatory agencies in Brazil, is engaged in an
    important debate about the effectiveness of its regulatory instruments rooted in the command
    and control perspective, which have largely proven ineffective in their objectives of shaping
    the behavior of regulated companies, leading to a legitimacy crisis in the performance of those
    agencies. In this context, pilot projects for responsive regulation were implemented by Anatel
    to test concepts of responsive regulation, which could lead to a review of the institutional
    framework for monitoring, control and inspection of regulatory obligations by Anatel, known
    within the Agency as regulatory inspection. Our research sought to discuss the implementation,
    on a pilot basis, of responsive regulation in consumer protection, focusing on the processes of
    regulatory oversight of undue charges of telecommunications services, particularly value-added
    services; and the responsive process of unwanted calls (telemarketing). Drawing from the
    literature on responsive regulation, we used the categories of analysis to evaluate the responsive
    pyramid, the organization of arenas for discussing processes and the publicity of strategic
    information. We added the evaluation of cooperation, commitment and coordination
    mechanisms to these categories, believing that the effectiveness of public policies is, to a large
    extent, related to building trust among the agents who participate or are impacted by them. In
    order to make the research operational, we carried out document analysis and semi-structured
    interviews with key executives of the telecommunications companies involved, with
    representatives of civil society who are members of the National Consumer Protection System
    and with the Anatel team that worked on the processes. Our findings suggest that responsive
    regulation at Anatel can be negatively impacted by the absence of effective mechanisms for the
    participation and coordination of interested third parties. The experimental nature contributes
    to the observed immaturity in stakeholder relationships. However, we believe that there is still
    room for a more robust procedural approach that promotes dialogue and trust between
    stakeholders.

12
  • ANNE KAROLINE RODRIGUES VIEIRA
  • SOCIAL MOVEMENTS AND THE FEMINIST ANTIRACIST PARLIAMENTARY FRONT IN THE ANTI-ABORTION BLOCK: TURNING LIMITS INTO POSSIBILITIES

  • Advisor : DEBORA CRISTINA REZENDE DE ALMEIDA
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • DEBORA CRISTINA REZENDE DE ALMEIDA
  • DANUSA MARQUES
  • REBECCA NEAERA ABERS
  • GISELA ZAREMBERG
  • NAARA LÚCIA DE ALBUQUERQUE LUNA
  • Data: Sep 15, 2023


  • Show Abstract
  • The discussion on the right to abortion goes beyond individual freedom, encompassing issues of justice, social equality, and women's autonomy. The criminalization of abortion has unequal impacts, primarily affecting women from lower socioeconomic classes, Black women, and those residing in peripheral areas. Such criminalization imposes restrictions and inequalities on women, harming their citizenship and social status. Despite some legal allowances for abortion in Brazil, these measures are limited and do not fully recognize women as rights holders. During the 56th legislature - the period analyzed in this study - proposals for restricting and even eliminating access to abortion in the country were observed, driven by conservative political actors and the Bolsonaro government, which attempted to diminish the state's capacity to provide this service. Even in a challenging context with seemingly closed opportunity structures, feminist movements have resisted and strived to prevent the approval of restrictive abortion proposals. The core of this research focuses on how these movements managed to thwart restrictive abortion proposals, even in a conservative and hostile political environment. The analysis adopted here is essentially relational, exploring both the actions of feminists and conservatives - painting a comprehensive picture of the actions and tactics adopted by conservatives in the National Congress - and how the former developed specific strategies in response. The focus is particularly on the Feminist Antiracist Parliamentary Front with Popular Participation, an entity of hybrid nature and composition that simultaneously embraces institutional characteristics and elements of a social movement network. The creation of the Parliamentary Front itself represents a tactic employed by both movements and parliamentarians, providing an effective platform for engaging in the abortion agenda. To achieve this, a collection of abortion-related propositions was carried out through the Information Systems of the Chamber of Deputies and the Federal Senate. The collection spanned from 2003 to December 2022 and included all types of legislative propositions. After a thorough analysis, propositions directly related to the expansion or restriction of the right to abortion were selected. This data was processed using SPSS software for descriptive statistical analysis. The focus on anti-abortion propositions indicated the parties that proposed the most, the profile of parliamentarians, and the status of these propositions at the end of the legislature. In addition, interviews were conducted with feminist organizations and movements involved in the debate on the decriminalization or legalization of abortion, as well as parliamentary advisors and a Ministry of Health technician, totaling 13 interviews. The analysis of the interviews was carried out with the assistance of NVIVO software, allowing the identification of relevant themes and the creation of codes to categorize qualitative data. Materials, such as reports, pamphlets, and online publications from feminist organizations, were also investigated. Based on the collected information and analyses, inferences were drawn about the role of feminist movements in blocking anti-abortion propositions during the study period. The adaptation of social movement strategies according to the analyzed political context is highlighted, seeking influence and support within institutional structures. Feminists intensified their interaction with the Legislature - through the Feminist Antiracist Parliamentary Front - seeking the support of feminist

    parliamentarians and engaging in blocking actions with their collaboration, allowing for an expansion of the feminist network and legislative coordination.

13
  • Gabriel Coelho Squeff
  • Party ideology, productive structure, and income distribution in Latin America in the 2000s

  • Advisor : ANDRE BORGES DE CARVALHO
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • ANDRE BORGES DE CARVALHO
  • ADRIAN NICOLAS ALBALA YOUNG
  • FREDERICO BERTHOLINI SANTOS RODRIGUES
  • NATÁLIA GUIMARÃES DUARTE SÁTYRO
  • SERGEI SUAREZ DILLON SOARES
  • Data: Sep 22, 2023


  • Show Abstract
  • Latin American countries experienced a significant reduction in income inequality in the 2000s due to the electoral victories by leftist presidential candidates. Although rich, the literature on the subject has at least three deficiencies: widespread adoption of Eurocentric theories, excessive focus on the ideology of the president, and disregard of the role of the productive structure.
    This research addresses these three shortcomings through a parsimonious and effectively Latin American political-economy approach. Using mixed methods research, I seek to answer the following questions: 1) What is the relationship between productive structure, party ideology and total income distribution in Latin America in the 2000s? 2) Why were some Latin American countries governed by left-wing parties more successful than others in reducing total income inequality in the post-2000 period?
    The theoretical model is developed in accordance with the two components of total income, namely primary income and government transfers. The main element of the first component is the income from production, addressed here through ECLAC’s structural heterogeneity approach. For government transfers, I used the theoretical contributions of power resource theory, the debate about the partisan powers of the president, and the literature that discusses the impact of the ideological difference of the chief executive vis-à-vis the average ideology of the Chamber of Deputies. Therefore, I called this theoretical approach the IPI model (I for inequality, P for productive and I for ideology).
    The first question was evaluated using descriptive statistics and panel data econometrics for 14 Latin American countries between 2000 and 2020. These estimates strongly support the DPI model, namely: (i) the more left-wing the president's ideology, (ii) the more left-wing the average ideology of the Chamber of Deputies, (iii) the smaller the share of the population employed in low labor productivity activities, (iv) the larger the share of the population employed in intermediate labor productivity activities and, finally, (v) the larger the left-wing caucus in the Chamber of Deputies, the lower total income inequality in Latin America.
    The second research question was addressed through case studies from a historical-institutional perspective. The experiences of Bolivia, with Evo Morales of the Movimiento al Socialismo - MAS, Brazil, with Lula and Dilma of the Partido dos Trabalhadores - PT, and Uruguay, with Tabaré Vázquez and José Mujica of the Frente Amplio - FA, were discussed in detail. Data from some social protection policies, the real minimum wage and the share of manufacturing in the Gross Domestic Product were incorporated into the IPI model.
    While in the MAS and FA governments there was a left-wing ideological convergence between the Executive and Legislative branches, in the PT governments the Chamber of Deputies remained dominated by right-wing parties. Similarly, the parties of Bolivia and Uruguay managed to form one-party governments, with more than half of the total seats in the Chamber of Deputies and a large left-wing caucus. In Brazil, the PT's share has always been less than 20\% and the left-wing caucus has never been a majority, which therefore required the formation of a multi-party coalition that resulted in an ideologically heterogeneous government.
    In the same vein, and largely as a result of these peculiarities, Bolivia and Uruguay have managed to substantially change their productive structures. There has been a significant reduction in the population employed in low-productivity economic activities and, conversely, an increase in higher-productivity activities. In Brazil, on the other hand, this change was much smaller and therefore much less conducive to a path of economic growth with income distribution.
    Therefore, tackling income inequality was much more favorable for Morales, Vázquez and Mujica than for Lula and Dilma. When the president and m

14
  • Gustavo Filice de Barros
  • INSTITUTIONAL CHANGE IN THE BRAZILIAN PROFESSIONAL EDUCATION SUBSYSTEM: A CASE STUDY.
     
  • Advisor : PAULO CARLOS DU PIN CALMON
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • ARNALDO MAUERBERG JUNIOR
  • KLEBER CHAGAS CERQUEIRA
  • LUIZ GUILHERME DE OLIVEIRA
  • MARCELO VIANA ESTEVAO DE MORAES
  • PAULO CARLOS DU PIN CALMON
  • Data: Oct 20, 2023


  • Show Abstract
  • This research had as its theme the professional education policy in Brazil and its institutionalization process. The focus of the analysis is centered on the action of the actors and their coalitions that defend their interests – or power –, in the policy formulation and decision-making processes of politics and their institutional changes, in the period from 1909 to 2008. The starting question that guided the works was: why did the institutionalization of professional education fail in Brazil ? Based on this questioning, the main objective was created: to analyze the evolution and changes that occurred in the professional education policy in Brazil, focusing on the political processes underlying its institutional dynamics. The specific objectives: I - trace and identify the evidence of coalition action of actors and their interests in the formulation of public policies on professional education; II - describe and analyze the trajectory of professional education institutions – norms, rules, practices and narratives – over time; and III - identify the institutional changes that occurred and the underlying causal mechanisms. The research line of this thesis is centered on the historical neoinstitutionalist theory, on the theory of the variety of capitalism (VoC), combined with the framework of gradual and abrupt institutional changes. The analysis started from the hypothesis that industrialists played a central role in the country's professional education policy, since, together with the State, they vetoed the participation of other actors in the decision-making processes. The research strategy adopted was the case study, with the use of theory-guides process tracing as methodology. The analysis was national and longitudinal in the sense of exploring and examining how the actors, contexts, trajectory and institutions (independent variables) were included in the temporal dimension to understand policy trajectories. Decision-making helped explain institutional changes (dependent variables – general education and specific education). The investigation had as sources of primary and secondary data, based on documental and bibliographical research and interviews. Official documents researched in the Chamber of Deputies, Federal Senate and the Executive (dossiers of norms and rules) were analyzed, in the CPDOC/FGV database (files: Nilo Peçanha, Getúlio Vargas, Gustavo Capanema) it was possible to access several documents that elucidated the narratives of the context. Also, the consulted scientific production and the interviews helped to argue about the institutional changes in the four analyzed periods. For data analysis, thematic content analysis was used, which aims to investigate the motivations of opinions, attitudes, values, beliefs, trends and others. It was concluded that the institutionalization of professional education was divided into two subsystems – one public and the other private – through the causal mechanism of institutional business power. This segregation process was reproduced over time, which allowed the existence of feedback and lock -in effects. In addition, the existence of this mechanism made it possible to institutionalize the advantage of dominant actors by vetoing the participation of actors, such as labor unions, in the policy decision-making process. Still, the ideal-type variety of hierarchical capitalism fits little with the characteristics of Brazilian capitalism, since there was a process of exclusion of actors, which seems to be little related to hierarchy. The causal mechanism of displacement was identified in three contexts, which reveals low veto power of the actors and low ability to interpret the rules. Thus, by the characteristics evidenced in the institutionalization of professional education in Brazil, it can be understood that there may have been a process of non-complementary between the institutional arrangements, which may have reflected in the socioeconomic development of the cou

15
  • Patrícia de Lucena Mourão
  • Women of the field, the waters, the forest and the esplanada:
    interactions, advances and challenges in the production of public policies

  • Advisor : FLAVIA MILLENA BIROLI TOKARSKI
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • LEONILDE SERVOLO DE MEDEIROS
  • CLARISSE GOULART PARADIS
  • DANUSA MARQUES
  • FLAVIA MILLENA BIROLI TOKARSKI
  • REBECCA NEAERA ABERS
  • Data: Dec 13, 2023


  • Show Abstract
  • In the context of advances and setbacks in policies for women, in general, and for rural women, in particular, this research aimed to understand the interactions between rural women's movements and the Directorate of Policies for Rural Women (DPMR) , as well as the effects of interactions on the actions of the Ministry of Agrarian Development (MDA) to combat gender inequalities in rural areas, including internal institutional reorganization efforts. From the perspective of state feminism, we sought to verify whether the Brazilian Federal Government has become more inclusive of rural women and their demands with the institution of the DPMR in the MDA; investigate to what extent the institutional changes undertaken by the MDA assume a feminist perspective and challenge patriarchy; and verify to what extent external institutionalities for rural women remained effective over time and in the face of the cyclical changes experienced in Brazil after 2016. Research was carried out using a set of qualitative process tracking techniques, which included the analysis of institutional documents related to the period from 2000 to 2023 and semi-structured interviews with leaders of women's organizations and representatives of the MDA. The main results of the research indicate that rural women have projected themselves onto the national political scene, as a fundamental political actor for transforming the way public policies are made for women; the DPMR became a prominent actor in the political process and in the production of these policies; interactions between the movement and DPMR produced the realization of women's rights related to access to documentation, land, technical assistance, public resources to structure their productive and economic activities and social participation; the effects of this alliance were also expressed in advances related to the representation of rural women in national councils, especially CONDRAF, CONSEA and CNAPO; where mechanisms were established to guarantee the participation of women and women's or gender committees were created in its structure, which favored the debate on inequalities in public policies and political participation; however, the policies, programs and actions achieved by rural women did not resist the changes undertaken by the government after 2016.

2022
Dissertations
1
  • ISABEL THAIS EIRADO MARTINS
  • Brazilian cultural heritage representation from the perspective of race relations: an evaluation of State narratives

  • Advisor : CARLOS AUGUSTO MELLO MACHADO
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • LÍLIA ROLIM ABADIA
  • CARLOS AUGUSTO MELLO MACHADO
  • DANUSA MARQUES
  • DEBORA CRISTINA REZENDE DE ALMEIDA
  • Data: Aug 9, 2022


  • Show Abstract
  • The work hereby presented aims to develop the concept of cultural heritage representation based on the literature of cultural heritage, racial studies, and representation. With means to apply and consolidate the concept, an empirical analysis examines, from the perspective of race relations, the candidature reports of Brazil’s tangible and intangible heritage recognized by the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) between 1980 and 2019. The process to integrate the World Heritage Lists begins at the federal sphere of the National Institute of Historic and Artistic Heritage (IPHAN) of Brazil, responsible for elaborating the candidatures and for its presentation at the international level, along with the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. The main purpose of analyzing those documents is to understand heritage representation in Brazil, with emphasis on the impacts of race relations. For that, the analysis considers symbolic representation, state narratives and institutions, entities and groups participating and integrating the cultural heritages in focus. In accordance with its goals, this dissertation is formed by a theoretical framework, a conceptual construction of the term cultural heritage representation, and a categorical analysis of the candidature documents of twenty Brazilian heritage sites that integrated the World Heritage Lists of UNESCO between 1980 and 2019.

2
  • Andeliton de Oliveira Soares
  • The usage of the parliament stage: how Brazilian deputies' speeches reveal different profiles of political ambition

  • Advisor : LUCIO REMUZAT RENNO JUNIOR
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • ADRIAN NICOLAS ALBALA YOUNG
  • FREDERICO BERTHOLINI SANTOS RODRIGUES
  • LUCIO REMUZAT RENNO JUNIOR
  • MARCELA MACHADO
  • Data: Oct 19, 2022


  • Show Abstract
  • The reelection is understood to be the main factor to explain politicians’ gravitational orbit. However, this stressed motivation by academic research does not explain the case of “new democracies” and show itself to be insufficient to understand the actions of politicians. Knowing how elected representatives commit their time and effort has meaningful implications. Aiming to explore different political types in Brazil’s Chamber of Deputies, this work develops an analysis of how political ambition can shape different profiles of deputies through their speech. Using unsupervised learning techniques to explore topic modelling, Latent Dirichlet Allocation (LDA), this research shows significant differences in the political ambition profile: legislators who demonstrate progressive ambition promote discussions concerning districts and specifical groups, display their actions in a public manner, pressure authorities inside and outside the Chamber to find solutions to different problems, pay homage and propel public figures, districts, and events. This content of speech shows itself to be remarkable in shaping different types of political profile of deputies in Brazil. Furthermore, the present research drives an important agenda of organizing the topics of parliamentary discussion in Brazil’s Chamber of Deputies.

3
  • Gabriela Leonardo Araujo
  • THE PERFORMANCE OF PUBLIC DEFENDERS IN THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE SOCIO-EDUCATIONAL SYSTEM IN TIMES OF PANDEMIC

  • Advisor : FREDERICO BERTHOLINI SANTOS RODRIGUES
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • FREDERICO BERTHOLINI SANTOS RODRIGUES
  • ADRIAN NICOLAS ALBALA YOUNG
  • MARISA VON BULOW
  • FLAVIA DANIELLE SANTIAGO LIMA
  • Data: Dec 8, 2022


  • Show Abstract
  • This work seeks to understand the implementation of public policies as a complex process involving diverse actors and decision-making. In this research we study the performance of the State and District Public Defender Offices, through the defenders who work in the Justice System, of legal assistance to adolescents in conflict with the law of the socio-educational policy, in a context of the COVID-19 pandemic in Brazil. The research was conducted in three stages through various methodological strategies. First, a documentary analysis of already available data was conducted, based on CNJ Recommendation N. 62/2020, the SINASE Evaluation Survey (2020) and the National Survey of the Public Defender's Office (2022). In the second part, the questionnaire was applied through an online survey in a single step, with a convenience sample, with 34 voluntary responses. In the third stage of the research, 6 interviews were conducted with Coordinators of the Public Defender's Offices linked to the area of Children and Youth, following a semi-structured script. Finally, a content analysis of the data produced and a triangulation of all the information was carried out. The general objective was to understand the role of the State and District Public Defenders in the implementation of the socio-educational policy in the context of the pandemic. From there, it was listed two specific objectives: a) Analyze to what extent this performance of the Public Defenders contributed to the guarantee or maintenance of violations of fundamental rights of adolescents in conflict with the law in this period of the Covid-19 pandemic; and b) Understand what factors influence the exercise of discretion of the State and District Public Defenders in the implementation of the Socio-Educational Policy. The dissertation aims to contribute to the studies on the implementation of public policies, especially in the scope of the Street Level Bureaucracy, in a context in which the State's presence has never been so demanded in the fight against the coronavirus and in the care of the Brazilian population.
4
  • João Pedro Estevão de Vasconcelos Martins
  • Presidential legislative activity in Latin American bicameralisms: an analysis of the mechanisms for solving bicameral disagreements

  • Advisor : ADRIAN NICOLAS ALBALA YOUNG
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • ADRIAN NICOLAS ALBALA YOUNG
  • ANDRE BORGES DE CARVALHO
  • FREDERICO BERTHOLINI SANTOS RODRIGUES
  • MARIA MERCEDES GARCÍA MONTERO
  • Data: Dec 14, 2022


  • Show Abstract
  • Bicameralism is a common institutional feature in Latin America, but frequently ignored in legislative studies. Considering this limitation, this research intends to contribute to the literature on presidential legislative activity by incorporating bicameral elements into the analysis of presidential legislative success from seven Latin American countries, using data that cover the legislative production since democratization. The dependent variable was the rate of presidential legislative success, understood as the proportion between approved leg- islative projects and the total number of legislative projects proposed by the executive branch. Concretely, three hypotheses that associate bicameral elements to the rate of presidential legislative success were tested. Those hypotheses include the veto power symmetry between both legislative chambers, the kinds of mechanisms for resolving bicameral conflicts and the size of presidential coalitions in both chambers. Results indicate that asymmetric powers for rejecting bills increase presidential success. Similarly, controlling bicameral majorities also favors the rate of presidential legislative success. On the other hand, the stated expectations about the effects for each mechanism for resolving bicameral conflicts did not succeed.

Thesis
1
  • Cleyton Feitosa Pereira
  • THE LGBTI+ MOVEMENT AND POLITICAL PARTIES: The partisan institutionalization of sexual and gender diversity in Brazil

  • Advisor : DEBORA CRISTINA REZENDE DE ALMEIDA
  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS :
  • CARLOS AUGUSTO MELLO MACHADO
  • DEBORA CRISTINA REZENDE DE ALMEIDA
  • JAMES NAYLOR GREEN
  • MATHEUS MAZZILLI PEREIRA
  • REBECCA NEAERA ABERS
  • Data: Dec 13, 2022


  • Show Abstract
  • This work is dedicated to the analysis of how the Movement of Lesbians, Gays, Bisexuals, Transgenders, Intersex, and other non-heterosexual and non-cisgender (LGBTI+) identities have been institutionalized in Brazilian political parties. We carried out a theoretical debate arranged towards the concept of institutionalization in the literature about social movements and political parties in order to understand this complex empirical phenomenon. After all, even before the country's re-democratization, LGBTI+ activists militate in political parties and transform these organizations establishing their values, goals, and interests. Through semi-structured interviews with party activists and documentary analysis in official documents, such as statutes, party programs, and government plans, among others, we executed a comparative study about the launch of sexual and gender diversity activism in the Partido dos Trabalhadores (PT), in the Partido Socialismo e Liberdade (PSOL) and the Partido Social Democracia Brasileira (PSDB), analyzing the process, factors, effectiveness, and barriers of its institutionalization. We focused on the statutes and the sectorial organization of the theme in each of the three cases concerning to understand the differences and similarities between them. Despite the differences and historical antagonism, PT and PSDB are the ones that share more similarities. Its secretariats are born as party nuclei in the city of São Paulo, despite the different periods of each one's emergence - PT in 1992 and PSDB only in 2006 - and its militants have been nationalizing the group, taking advantage of the power of São Paulo's LGBTI+ Pride Parade as a tourist attraction to foster a national political organization. The main difference lies in the fact that the PT has a much more imbricated relationship with unions and movements than the PSDB, which has a less social base. In the PT case, it is impossible to separate a partisan actor from a social movement activist (and in some cases, also a trade union actor), unlike the Tucana Diversity, which is more clearly composed of partisan actors that eventually relate to social movements. The PSOL was the most dissimilar case because of its low degree of institutionalization of the national sector. The party has some sectors organized at the state level, mainly in central Brazilian states, such as São Paulo, Rio de Janeiro, and the Federal District, but it has not consolidated its LGBTI+ national sector, with meetings, agendas, priorities, and strategies. On the other hand, PT and PSDB inaugurated their statutes without mentioning the struggle for sexual and gender diversity, instituting this issue only after a previous political organization of activists within them. Unlike the PSOL, which was born already affirming this flag since its foundation. The analysis of the zones of uncertainty shows that engaged actors still have little access to and control of vital areas for the functioning of parties, such as communications, decisions, funding, and recruitment. This shows that a part of Brazilian parties is sensitive to the theme, but with limits. The limits seem to come up against precisely in the process of sharing the power and the resources. After managing to introduce the theme and make the parties distribute collective identity incentives, the next challenge is to access and control the resources of organizational power. Finally, after the empirical results, we propose a concept of institutionalization for the study of the interaction between social movements and political parties.

SIGAA | Secretaria de Tecnologia da Informação - STI - (61) 3107-0102 | Copyright © 2006-2024 - UFRN - app30_Prod.sigaa24